The Truth has Light. But not Fake Shaykhs

the truth has light. Don't be misled by fake shaykhs


‘They want to extinguish the light of Allah Almighty but Allah Almighty will complete His light, even though the disbelievers dislike it’. (9:32 and 61:8)

Allah Almighty is highlighting the fact that whenever we have the truth, there are always enemies against it. The truth always faces challenges. How can we identify those who are misrepresenting and tarnishing Islam by commercialising and politicising the deen?

The Challenge to the Truth

Throughout our history today until the Day of Judgement, there is an on-going challenge between truth and falsehood. Ever since, Allah Almighty sent the prophets and messengers to deliver the truth and to establish justice in society for all people, they faced with many enemies.

The most difficult challenge is in our deen – our religion, the cord that connects us with Allah Almighty. Whoever clings fast to this rope will be saved, and whoever lets go, will bear the consequences of that choice.

Since the prophets and the messengers are gone, we have their representatives as the Prophet (peace be upon him) said:

The scholars are the heirs of the prophets.

(Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud, Nasa’i, Ibn Maja, Ahmad, Ibn Hibban)

They too inevitably face similar challenges, enemies, and plots against them and the message. The enemies are very shrewd and they know how to strike and they know that if destroy religious authority, you can destroy the deen.

Tactics to Undermine Islam

It is harder to attack the Qur’an or the Sunnah directly, even though this has been happening since orientalism started, so they choose a different strategy. They select a figure in the community who claims to be a person of knowledge, but his knowledge is either distorted or ignorant, and as a result, it leads to the misrepresentation of Islam. They deliver fatwas left, right and centre, throw wild opinions all over the place in the name of Islam.

The consequences of such figures and the publicity they get, are that they put people off Islam, particularly young people, who disagree with their bigoted views. Even though their views and interpretations are not in line with mainstream Islam they tarnish the whole religion.

This is not a new challenge. When Allah Almighty stated in surah Baqarah, when He was addressing the People of the Book:

Do not exchange my revelation for a cheap price. (2:41)

We should not commercialise the religion. Religion is not a source of living or a business.

The Qur’an uses the verb ishtara here and in many verses, which is an expression of both buying and selling. It is telling us not to sell our deen and not to exchange it for something which is cheap. We have been honoured by being given the truth so we have to stand up and defend it.

We’ve seen throughout the history of humanity that the temptation to commercialise the deen, and make it a source of wealth, has corrupted many.

The challenge started, when shaytan declared his promise to Allah Almighty that he would distort and deform the message as much as possible, and whisper as much as possible.

(Iblis) said: ‘By Your glory, I shall mislead them all. except those of Your servants, the chosen ones from amongst them. (38:82-83)

The challenge is on-going, and today isn’t different to yesterday. It’s the same.

Fake Shaykhs

After the so-called Arab Spring, many scholars collapsed, many dignified people became undignified, their veils dropped. The masks were stripped away. They were exposed for who they really were. This confirms the reality of what Allah Almighty stated in the Qur’an, that they want to extinguish the Light of Allah Almighty, but they can’t.

Within our country we have seen similar figures misrepresenting the Muslim community being supported by some politicians.

We see from our history, there has usually been a divorce between governments and scholars, with some exceptions, but almost all respected scholars keep their distance from the government. They do not work to support the government. They are neutral, not on the payroll of those in authority.

Neutral scholars have the recipe for success, but those who are working for this governor or this president or that institute, they might, and have many times, distorted Islam. Unfortunately, we’ve seen many of these in our time.

Alhamdulillah people are still clear what the truth is, but sometimes it’s confusing. Men in big turbans with long beards deliver speeches to justify why their rulers are killing their people. Or to justify why the government has sent forces to crush people in demonstrations, or to justify why they throwing hordes of people in prison, and killing people outside their country.

How can you condone heinous acts in the name of Islam. Say you agree with it in your opinion, but don’t drag Islam into it. Don’t say that it is acceptable from a shariah point of view.

Such fatwas will make people hate Islam and use them as a weapon against it. Our youth will turn against Islam when they see ‘Islam’ being used to defend oppression, and support oppressors.

This is not Islam! This is deformed. This is distorted. This has nothing to do with Islam at all.

In this country there are certain foundations and organisations and institutions being supported by the government to represent the Muslim community, and unfortunately they are spreading fatwas everywhere to approve what the government says, because they are being funded by the government.

Who gave them the right to represent us?

Identifying the Truth

We need to be very clear that the truth lies in the Qur’an, the Sunnah, and the truth lies with those who are sincerely committed to this message. Not committed to their bank account. Not committed to what position they will receive. Not committed to their self-interest.

Allah Almighty warned our community that we would face many challenges, but  the Light of the Truth is very bright, like sunlight, even more! So don’t be deceived by these people. Don’t be deceived by them even if they are popular.

Ibn ul Mubarak and Tirmidhi and Ibn Hibban narrated that Muawiya sent a letter to Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) when he was governor in Sham and asked for a short piece of advice, she responded, ‘The Messenger of Allah Almighty (peace be on him) said:

‘Whoever seeks to please Allah Almighty by doing something which displeases people, Allah Almighty will be pleased with him and the people will be pleased with him.

And whoever seeks to please people by displeasing Allah Almighty, Allah Almighty will be displeased by him and the people will be displeased by him.’

It is straightforward – we are seeking Allah Almighty’s pleasure. We should not seek the government’s pleasure if they are in the wrong, we should not seek anyone’s pleasure who is in the wrong, but we should always be seeking Allah Almighty’s pleasure, because this is where the truth lies.

Wherever the truth lies, follow it.

This is your compass; your direction. It’s like your qibla direction. Just as you find your direction to pray, find your direction in life by following the truth.

Do not to be deceived by anyone who claims he is following the truth. We judge people according to the Book of Allah Almighty, and the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace be upon him). We don’t judge the truth by people.

We have already identified the problem almost- what is the solution? The solution is to learn the truth from authentic sources, from authentic reliable authorities.

How to tell who is authentic and reliable?

  • Piety and Knowledge

You can tell from  their knowledge and their piety and their understanding of reality.

  • Understanding of Life Today

It’s not enough to be a person of knowledge of the books, you have to understand the world we live, and apply that knowledge to our lives.

  • Independent

Scholars should always be independent. They should be supporting any particular party or government, or politicians.

This is why throughout our history we used to have something called a waqf ul ulama – a special endowment for scholars, to keep their opinions absolutely unbiased and pure. So, we need to create such endowments for the scholars, to secure their independence and secure their future InshAllah.

We need to keep Islam pure from commercialisation and politicisation.

May Allah enable us to see the truth and support the truth.

Khutbah delivered by Shaykh Haytham Tamim at the Muslim World League

Transcribed by Sana Zuberi

Related Posts

When Scholars and Leaders Fail

When we have to obey leaders and scholars and when we don’t

Why we cannot deny the sunnah

Defending the Four Schools

Do I need a Shaykh?

How do I know who is the best teacher for me?

How to receive the light of Allah in your heart


Shaykh Haytham Tamim is the founder and main teacher of the Utrujj Foundation. He has provided a leading vision for Islamic learning in the UK, which has influenced the way Islamic knowledge is disseminated. He has orchestrated the design and delivery of over 200 unique courses since Utrujj started in 2001. His extensive expertise spans over 30 years across the main Islamic jurisprudence schools of thought. He has studied with some of the foremost scholars in their expertise; he holds some of the highest Ijazahs (certificates) in Quran, Hadith (the Prophetic traditions) and Fiqh (Islamic rulings). His own gift for teaching was evident when he gave his first sermon to a large audience at the age of 17 and went on to serve as a senior lecturer of Islamic transactions and comparative jurisprudence at the Islamic University of Beirut (Shariah College). He has continued to teach; travelling around the UK, Europe and wider afield, and won the 2015 BISCA award (British Imams & Scholars Contributions & Achievements Awards) for Outstanding Contribution to Education and Teaching.